Owners rarely change property managers over one bad month. They stay too long, because nothing is obviously broken. The rent comes in, the lights are on, and the monthly report arrives, eventually. What is wrong is quieter than that: the building is being administered, not managed.
This is the eleventh article in a series on how to read your own building. It is for the owner who has started to wonder whether the problem is the market, the building or the manager. Below are the six signs we would look for from the outside, what each one usually means, and a worked example of what two of them cost.
Administration keeps a building running. Rent is collected, bills are paid, and a vendor answers the service call. Management decides things: which renewal needs a conversation this quarter, which vendor price needs checking, and what the building will need in three years and how it will be paid for.
An administered building can look fine for years. The cost shows up in the rent it did not earn and the expenses nobody questioned. None of the six signs below proves anything on its own. Any two of them together usually do.
The monthly report is how an owner sees the building. When it arrives late in the following month, the owner is reading about decisions that were made, or not made, three weeks earlier. A late report usually means the books are closed by hand, or the report is assembled after the fact instead of kept as the month goes. Either way, the owner is the last to know.
Every vacant suite needs a plan on paper: the asking rent and the reason for it, what the space needs before it shows well, which brokers have it, and which concessions the owner will accept. If a suite has been dark for three months and nobody can hand the owner that page, the suite is being listed, not leased. The fifth article in this series showed that a dark month costs closer to three months of rent than one.
The annual reconciliation is the one document in which the owner tells every tenant what the building cost to run and asks them to pay for it. The lease usually sets a deadline for it. A manager who misses that deadline, or who sends a reconciliation that tenants dispute every year, is either not reading the leases or not building a reconciliation a tenant can check.
Roofs, rooftop units, parking lots and elevators wear out on a schedule their age sets. A manager who plans ahead tells the owner about them a year or more in advance, with a number attached. When capital work arrives as an emergency call followed by an invoice, there was no plan, and emergency work almost always costs more than planned work.
Every invoice should trace back to a request: a tenant call, a scheduled service visit, an inspection, or a repair the owner approved. Pick one invoice at random. If nobody can say what it was for, who asked for it and whether anyone checked the work, then nobody is checking the others either. This is where costs drift without anyone deciding to spend the money.
This is the one that matters most. The other five are symptoms, and this one is usually the cause. A manager who is stretched across too many buildings, or who has handed yours to someone without the authority to decide, cannot do the work that management requires. If a question about your own building takes three days to answer, so does every problem.
The figures are illustrative, not a property we manage.
A 32,000-square-foot multi-tenant office building. Rents average $24 per square foot a year, and the tenants reimburse operating costs of about $9 per square foot. Two of the six signs are present.
The first is a 4,000-square-foot suite that has been vacant for seven months with no written leasing plan. Each dark month costs $8,000 in rent and about $3,000 in operating costs the owner now carries alone, $11,000 in all. Suppose a plan written the day the tenant gave notice would have had the suite leased in four months instead of seven. The three extra months cost $33,000.
The second is the repair line. The HVAC contractor's service agreement calls for a maintenance visit every quarter at $1,200 a visit, but last year the contractor billed every month. Nobody tied the invoices to the agreement, so eight visits the agreement never called for were paid: $9,600.
Together that is $42,600 in one year, from two signs, on one building. Neither number appears on the monthly report as a problem. Both appear as ordinary lines: a vacancy, and repairs and maintenance.
Count the signs. If you find one, write it down and raise it with your manager; a single sign is often fixable in one conversation. If you find two or more, get an outside read before you decide anything.
Changing managers is a bigger decision than it looks, and the order matters. Our article on changing commercial property managers explains why the first step is a written operating read, with your costs and rents set next to comparable buildings, rather than a sales call.
Gain Property Group manages office, retail, industrial and multifamily property across Hillsborough, Pinellas, Pasco, Polk, Manatee and Sarasota counties. We also own commercial buildings ourselves, in other markets, so we read these numbers the way an owner does.
If you own commercial property in Tampa Bay and recognise two or more of these signs in your own building, request a free management assessment. In writing, no obligation, whether or not you change managers.
This article is general information about commercial and multifamily property operations. It is not investment, legal or tax advice.